Since some time there has been discussions about having a place for community reviews; see for example (Ingrid Daubechies) Planning for the World Digital Mathematical Library https://mathoverflow.net/questions/122125/math-annotate-platform https://meta.mathoverflow.net/questions/3088/community-peer-review-in-mathoverflow The idea is to have a transparent peer-review process. Everything should work as if it were a standard journal, except for the fact that submissions are linked to… Read more

About OpenReview OpenReview aims to promote openness in scientific communication, particularly the peer review process, by providing a flexible cloud-based web interface and underlying database API enabling the following: Open Peer Review: We provide a configurable platform for peer review that generalizes over many subtle gradations of openness, allowing conference organizers, journals, and other “reviewing… Read more